Ida Minerva Tarbell (1857-1944) — Journalist, Muckraker

 

Ida Tarbell Library of Congress LC-USZ62-117944

Ida Tarbell
Photo: Library of Congress
Digital ID cph 3c17944

Introduction: Ida Minerva Tarbell was born on a farm in Hatch Hollow, Pa., on Nov. 5, 1857. Her parents were Franklin S. Tarbell and Esther Ann McCullough Tarbell. When oil was discovered in Pennsylvania her father became the first manufacturer of wooden oil tanks. The family moved to Rouseville, a village on Oil Creek, and later to Titusville….Her “History of the Standard Oil,” which first appeared in McClure’s Magazine in nineteen installments, in 1904, was published in two volumes and drew immediate attention to the author. Her early reputation as a “trust buster” did not last, for she had in a high degree developed a sense of fairness, and this was particularly reflected in her “Life of Judge Gary,” in which – contrary to all expectations – she had nothing but praise for Judge Gary.

Ida Tarbell was the lone woman to enter Allegheny College in the fall of 1876. Coeducation was still an experiment, and there were only four other women students. But by Miss Tarbell’s senior year, the girls were at Allegheny to stay, thanks to the erection of the first women’s dormitory, growing out of a “coeducation campaign” in which Miss Tarbell herself played an important part. Throughout her life Miss Tarbell was closely in touch with the College. She earned an M.S. degree in 1883 and was awarded two honorary degrees – L.H.D. in 1909, and LL.D. in 1915. For more than thirty years she was a member of the College board of trustees. (Source: New York Times, 17 January, 1944)

Career: Ida Tarbell was one of the most successful magazine writers in the United States during the last century.  She wrote important stories at a time when women had few social or political rights.

Ida Tarbell used her reporting skills against one of the most powerful companies in the world.  That company was Standard Oil.  Ida Tarbell charged that Standard Oil was using illegal methods to hurt or destroy smaller oil companies. She investigated these illegal business dealings and wrote about them for a magazine called McClure’s.  The reports she wrote led to legal cases that continued all the way to the Supreme Court of the United States.

Ida Tarbell was born in the eastern state of Pennsylvania in November, 1857.  Her family did not have much money.  Her father worked hard but had not been very successful. When Ida was three years old, oil was discovered in the nearby town of Titusville.  Her father entered the oil business.  He struggled as a small businessman to compete with the large oil companies. Ida’s mother had been a school teacher.  She made sure that Ida attended school.  She also helped the young girl learn her school work. Ida wanted to study science at college.  Most people at that time thought it was not important for young women to learn anything more than to read and write.  Most people thought educating women was a waste of money. Ida’s parents, however, believed education was important — even for women.  They sent her to Allegheny College in nearby Meadville, Pennsylvania.  She was 19.

Those who knew Ida Tarbell in college say she would wake up at four o’clock in the morning to study.  She was never happy with her school work until she thought it was perfect.  In 1880, Ida finished college.  In August of that year, she got a teaching job in Poland, Ohio. It paid $500 a year. Miss Tarbell learned that she was expected to teach subjects about which she knew nothing.  She was able to do so by reading the school books before the students did.  She was a successful teacher, but the work, she decided, was too difficult for the amount she was paid.  So she returned home after one year.  A small newspaper in the town of Meadville soon offered her a job.

Many years later, Ida Tarbell said she had never considered being a writer.  She took the job with the newspaper only because she needed the money.  At first, she worked only a few hours each week. Later, however, she was working 16 hours a day.  She discovered that she loved to see things she had written printed in the paper.  She worked very hard at becoming a good writer. Miss Tarbell enjoyed working for the newspaper.  She discovered, though, that she was interested in stories that were too long for the paper to print.  She also wanted to study in France.  To earn money while in Paris, she decided she would write for American magazines.

Ida Tarbell found it difficult to live in Paris without much money.  She also found it difficult to sell her work to magazines.  The magazines were in the United States.  She was in Paris.  Some of her stories were never used because it took too long for them to reach the magazine.  Yet she continued to write.

Several magazines soon learned that she was a serious writer. A man named Samuel McClure visited Miss Tarbell in Paris.  He owned a magazine named McClure’s.  Mr. McClure had read several of her stories.  He wanted her to return to the United States and work for his magazine.  She immediately understood that this was a very good offer.  But she said no.  She proposed that she write for McClure’s from Paris.

Ida Tarbell wrote many stories for McClure’s.  She did this for some time before returning to the United States.  Her writing was very popular.  She helped make McClure’s one of the most successful magazines of its day. One of her first jobs for the magazine was a series of stories about the life of the French Emperor Napoleon.  The series was printed in McClure’s Magazine in 1894.  It was an immediate success.  The series was later printed as a book. It was very popular for a number of years.

Her next project was a series about the life of American President Abraham Lincoln.  She began her research by talking with people who had known him.  She used nothing they told her, however, unless she could prove it was true to the best of her ability. McClure’s Magazine wanted a short series about President Lincoln.  But Ida Tarbell’s series lasted for one year in the magazine.  Like her series about Napoleon, the President Lincoln stories were immediately popular.  They helped sell more magazines.  She continued her research about President Lincoln. Through the years, she would write eight books about President Lincoln.

Miss Tarbell’s reports about the Standard Oil Company were her most important work. Her 19-part series “The History of the Standard Oil Company” appeared in McClure’s Magazine beginning in 1902. The series was a masterpiece of investigative journalism that effectively broke up Standard Oil’s monopoly and helped to usher in the Progressive Era (King, 2012).

Tarbell’s reports showed that Standard Oil used illegal methods to make other companies lose business.  One method was to sell oil in one area of the country for much less than the oil was worth.  This caused smaller companies in that area to fail.  They could not sell their oil for that low a price and still make a profit.  After a company failed, Standard Oil would then increase the price of its oil.  This kind of unfair competition was illegal.

Miss Tarbell had trouble discovering information about the Standard Oil Company.  She tried to talk to businessmen who worked in the oil business.  At first, few would agree to talk. They were afraid of the Standard Oil Company and its owner, John D. Rockefeller.  He was one of the richest and most powerful men in the world.  Miss Tarbell kept seeking information.  She was told by one man that Rockefeller would try to destroy McClure’s Magazine.  But she did not listen to the threats.  She soon found evidence that Standard Oil had been using unfair and illegal methods to destroy other oil companies.  Soon many people were helping her find the evidence she needed.  Ida Tarbell’s investigations into Standard Oil were partly responsible for later legal action by the federal government against the company.  The case began in 1906.  In 1911, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled against Standard Oil because of its illegal dealings.  The decision was a major one.  It forced the huge company to separate into thirty-six different companies.

“The Crusaders” by C Hassmann. Ida Tarbell at center on black horse.
Puck, Feb. 21, 1906
Image: Library of Congress LC-DIG-ppmsca-26036

 

John D. Rockefeller never had to appear in court himself.  Yet the public felt he was responsible for his company’s illegal actions.  The investigative work of Ida Tarbell helped form that public opinion.  That investigative work continues to be what she is known for, even though some of her later writings defended American business.

In 1906, Tarbell, Baker, Steffens, and editor John Phillips left McClure’s and bought American Magazine, where they departed from the muckraking style and adopted a more optimistic approach. She and most of the rest of the staff left the magazine in 1915. During this time, Tarbell also contributed to Collier’s Weekly.

“The History of the Standard Oil Company” would be hailed as a landmark in the history of investigative journalism, as well as the most comprehensive study of the building of Rockefeller’s oil empire. In 1999, it was listed number five among the top 100 works of 20th-century American journalism. Having become one of the most influential women in the country, Ida Tarbell went on to pursue numerous writing and lecturing engagements. However, she rejected the status of role model. In spite of her accomplishments as a woman working at the turn of the century, she opposed the suffrage movement, arguing that traditional female roles had been belittled by women’s rights advocates and that women’s contributions belonged in the private sphere. She died of pneumonia in 1944, at the age of 86.

Tarbell’s other books included Life of Abraham Lincoln (1900), The Business of Being a Woman (1912), The Ways of Women (1915), biographies of Elbert H. Gary (1925) and Owen D. Young (1932), The Nationalizing of Business, 1878-1898 (1936), and her autobiography, All in the Day’s Work (1939).

She died of pneumonia in 1944, at the age of 86.

On October 7, 2000, Tarbell was inducted into the National Women’s Hall of Fame in Seneca Falls, New York. On September 14, 2002, the United States Postal Service issued a commemorative stamp honoring Tarbell as part of a series of four stamps honoring women journalists.

 

These volumes may also be read through the Internet Archive. Vol. 1; Vol. 2

For further reading:

Brady, Kathleen (1984). Ida Tarbell: Portrait of a Muckraker. New York, NY: Seaview/Putnam.

King, Gilbert (2012). The Woman Who Took on the Tycoon. Smithsonian.com. July 5, 2012.

Kochersberger Jr., Robert C., ed. (1995) More Than a Muckraker: Ida Minerva Tarbell’s Lifetime in Journalism, The University of Tennessee Press.

Tarbell, Ida M. (1939). All in the Day’s Work. New York, NY: The Macmillan Co.

Tarbell, Ida M. Works available at Internet Archive.

 

Sources:

King, Gilbert (2012). The Woman Who Took on the Tycoon. Smithsonian.com. July 5, 2012.

Piascik, A. Ida Tarbell: The Woman Who Took On Standard Oil. ConnecticutHistory.Org

Voice of America Special English: http://learningenglish.voanews.com/a/a-23-a-2003-10-11-2-1-83115397/121277.html

PBS: The American Experience: www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/…/rockefellers-tarbell/

 

One Response to Tarbell, Ida Minerva

  1. Betsey says:

    I’m not easily imsepserd but you’ve done it with that posting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *